Working with Rob Riddle was fantastic. He found us the perfect home, exactly what we were looking for. His knowledge and expertise of the area made everything simple. The best part is Rob was always available no matter what day or time to field our calls and help us seal the deal. We could not ask for a better realtor and he will be recommended to anyone I know looking to buy or sell a house!

- Adam Mott

We had a great experience working with Bev Klein at New Albany Realty. This was our first home purchase and we were not familiar with New Albany area. She was patient enough to show us many houses and help us understand and make choices. She made our first home purchase seamless.

- Pavan B

David did a fantastic job. He was always readily available to answer our questions and concerns. We will be keeping the word out about him and Thomas & Company for our family and friends!

- Erin Harris & Kristina Rawson

Bev's caring attention and knowledge of the marketplace is the only reason we were able to purchase this home that we love. Thank you.

- Lisa and John Pettit

Very excited about our new home! The Team at Thomas and Company worked incredibly hard to make our dream become a reality.

- Dan and Jessie Evans

I would highly recommend Rob Riddle at New Albany Realty. My wife and I would encourage anyone looking to sell and/or purchase a home in New Albany to contact Rob specifically. 100% Satisfied!! Thanks Rob!!

- John and Jennifer Scharver

I have never had a property purchase go so smoothly. David Evans handled every detail in a professional manner. Thanks so much David!

- Jon Cherrington

Tony got over list price from the first buyers to book a showing! Bev found us our dream home and we were able to close on both properties in the same day!

- Sarah and Andrew Goldsmith

Kate & Tony & the team gets the job done! They are professional, friendly, and competent. There is a reason they have the best reputation for integrity and results when it comes to buying and selling luxury real estate in Central Ohio.

- Cherie and Jim Nelson

Hard to believe you've been doing this for 20 years and doing it with such integrity, character and love for your clients. Well done and thank you both for helping us with our transactions.  

- Jim and Josie Harris

Rob Riddle was great to work with. Very personable, knowledgeable and responsive. Tony was very helpful. Very good organization. They pay real attention to customers. I will list with them again.

- Ramzi and Leslie Najjar

We listed our home on Thursday evening, had five showings Saturday morning/afternoon, three offers Saturday night, and went into contract - above asking price - Sunday morning. THANK YOU!

- Erich Goodlett

I met Kate 16 years ago before moving to New Albany . We were deciding between two areas. I asked Kate to take her realtor hat off and asked which area she thought we would be happier. She suggested the area (in which we built) and received no commission. We lived there 16 years and have been extremely happy! We just sold with the help of Tony and Kate. They went over and beyond. Thanks Kate for giving me the best 16 years of my life in New Albany.

- Jakki Allen

Rob helped us get the property we wanted. His service was great throughout the whole experience! We took many months to find the write place for us and he was patient. He really knew the area which helped us find the right spot. I would use him again and recommend him to anyone I know.

- Jake Worley

We have truly had a wonderful experience working with New Albany Realty! Rob Riddle was always very honest and kind with us while we were trying to decide whether or not we wanted to buy an existing home or build. He took a lot of time to show us many different options. We ended up building our dream home, but because of Rob and his expertise, we felt confident that we were making the right decision for our family. We recently moved in and are thrilled with the decision Rob helped us make. We highly recommend New Albany Realty and Rob Riddle to help you find your dream home!

- Elizabeth and Chris Clark

Bev was great. She made sure we got the house of our dreams and then sold our current home in 5 days. She managed every detail of the process expertly.

- Debbie Terry

Very happy with the service you provided for both buying and selling our condos. Very pleased with Bev and Sue and how hard they worked to meet our needs. Very pleasant experience buying our new condo and selling our old condo. We would recommend Bev and Sue to our friends and family. Thank you for all you did to make both sales positive!

- Gregory and JoAnn Althoff

Rob and his team went above and beyond and guided us through our complicated sale and our purchase. We highly recommend them!! Thank you with all our hearts!!

- Joanne and Ronald Beasy

We appreciate Sue so much! Thank you for walking us through the purchase of our first home and never letting us feel lost along the way! We look forward to many years together in our new home!

- Jared Rogers and Samantha Korba

Kate and Tony were absolutely incredible to work with. We bought our first house through them and the process was seamless. Kate was always available to help us and walked us through the entire process. We definitely recommend their services!

- Lauren Beran

We have truly had a wonderful experience working with New Albany Realty! Rob Riddle was always very honest and kind with us while we were trying to decide whether or not we wanted to buy an existing home or build. He took a lot of time to show us many different options. We ended up building our dream home, but because of Rob and his expertise, we felt confident that we were making the right decision for our family. We recently moved in and are thrilled with the decision Rob helped us make. We highly recommend New Albany Realty and Rob Riddle to help you find your dream home!

- Elizabeth Malys-Clark

Rob and team were absolutely wonderful and patient in selling my house and getting me a new one. Rob was with me the entire process and made time for my crazy schedule. I truly appreciate the whole team. Will absolutely recommend them.

- Sheila Kwarteng

I worked predominately with Rob Riddle and could not have had a better experience.

The fact that he was doing everything in his power to provide his clients with the best possible service was overwhelmingly evident. He was professional, responded to all inquiries extremely prompt, and was knowledgeable about everything that came up. He seemed to truly care about me and most definitely went the extra mile to do everything in his power to make the whole process a great experience. I ended up with a home that met all my needs despite the very challenging market. Even after close, Rob would always respond and help answer any inquiries and concerns.

I would strongly recommend Rob and Thomas Realty to anyone in need of a realtor.

- Mitchell Challacombe

The company is fantastic. Our personal realtor Bev was the best ever. She worked extremely hard 7 days a week to sell our home and to help find us a new one. We are grateful for her patience. When Bev wasn't available someone else from the office stepped in and took care of us.

- Jeremy Williams

Had a great experience with Tony. Nobody knows the New Albany market like he does. Everyone from his agency was knowledgeable, respectful, and very efficient at making sure my sale was successful and quick as possible. Thanks again!

- Jason Helmbrecht

We recently had the pleasure of working with Rob Riddle from New Albany Realty to sell our home. The home had many challenges that made it difficult in the past to sell. However, Rob and New Albany Realty were able to help us overcome the challenges and sell the home quickly. New Albany Realty's state of the art marketing process gave us an incredible amount of showings in a short amount of time. Throughout the process, we were continually impressed with Rob's knowledge and friendliness. The company also has a back office support team in place to assist with coordinating remedy requests and other paperwork. It is truly a team effort. We truly believe they are far and away better than any other real estate company we've ever worked with. We will be recommending them to friends and family every chance we get!

- Chris and Molly McKinney

Knowledgeable! Fast! Good communication!

- Charlie Park

My husband and I wouldn't have gotten our house if it wasn't for Rob. I met Rob at an open house. I was working with another realtor, but Rob's demeanor and wealth of knowledge made me question my current realtor. Rob was patient and made us feel like we were his only clients. When we found our house, there were already multiple offers. Rob's strategy secured us the home. In addition to our great experience with Rob, the office team was also extremely helpful in the closing process. Andrea and Dave were proactive in ensuring we had planned for all the necessary closing and other items. They also provided us with recommendations for painters, contractors, etc. We have ZERO complaints and will recommend Rob and team to our friends. When we are ready for our next home, we know who to call. Thank you!

- Ashley and Ed Niskala

Kate was outstanding from our first contact. We looked at many homes (over six days worth) and she found us the perfect home. Closing was seamless. I would recommend Kate and Tony to any of our friends!

- Ed and Jan Reeg

We worked with team member Rob Riddle on both the sale and purchase of a home, and he was excellent. His knowledge of the area and all the technical aspects of real estate transactions was very impressive. We had a full price offer on the first day of listing, but due to several setbacks along the way (no fault of Rob's), it took over two months to close. His efforts to "make it happen" on both ends of the selling/buying process were invaluable. We would recommend Thomas and Company, and Rob, without hesitation.

- Mike Mott

Kate & Tony and their team bring real passion to supporting their clients, resulting in a superior home selling/purchasing experience. They command our respect, trust and continuing business!

- Brain and Jeannette Newton

Rob Riddle did an amazing job finding the house that I wanted and was incredibly patient with me throughout the process. Everything was perfect with the staff - the reminders that they sent were a huge help and I loved the packet of information that I received at closing! I've never had a better home buying experience.

- Brittany Cummins
David Evans of New Albany Realty was wonderful to work with. Very responsive and helpful. He was experienced and very personable. We would definitely contact him again for any future sale or purchase!
- Kellie Kesselring

Amazing job – Great job guiding us on the purchase of our new home. Great value!! Also, great marketing with the house we sold. Got our asking price in 3 days. Doesn’t get any better than that. Thanks for all your team’s hard work!

- Tyler and Leslie Mills

We were delighted to work with the team at New Albany Realty! From Tony to Sue to everyone in the office, our home purchase in the Fenway section of New Albany CC was an incredible experience. We highly recommend New Albany Realty, as they listen, show only appropriate parties and make the buying experience a total pleasure! Tony gave us a great overview of the market. Sue Milne has been an absolutely fabulous partner through the sale closings and networking with contractors. Thomas & Company is the best!!!! Thank you all! What a great experience!

- Steve and Debbie King

I have worked with other realtors and real estate companies in the past and none compare to the great experience I had working with Rob Riddle and New Albany Realty. Rob was very accessible, responsive and extremely knowledgeable of the local market.

- Nick Sellitto

Knowledgeable! Fast! Good Communication! 

- Charlie Park

David went well above and beyond for everything. From last minute showings to helping us find several different contractors, he was great! Super responsive - overall amazing!

- Eric Segal and Allegra Flohr

Rob Riddle made himself available whenever we needed him. I would highly recommend him.

- Steve Senser

Our first time buying a home - we weren't sure what to expect, but Rob Riddle & Team at New Albany Realty couldn't have been easier to work with or more helpful & knowledgeable. We were impressed from our first experience with Rob right through to closing & getting our keys. This team made the process incredibly easy for us! Thank you!!

- Lydia Featheringill

Kate & Tony are the best! We had an outstanding experience. You really are THE New Albany Realtors. Why would anyone looking to buy or sell in New Albany even consider anyone else?

- Tim and Jennifer Glover

Sue was tremendous throughout a difficult process. I wouldn’t have wanted anyone else by my side – she is amazing! Bev sold my house in 1 day – wonderful job!

- Lindsay Hinderer


Bev was amazing! She always made herself available and was responsive to even the most ridiculous texts. We were extremely happy with our experience and would not have ended up with our dream home without her.

- Adam and Mallory Beane

Tony and the team did a great job getting our home sold in what turned out to be a more difficult market than we had anticipated. And Andrea was fabulous in attending to details leading up to our closing!

- Rob and Judy Meyer

We were very impressed with Bev Klein. She showed us properties that appealed to exactly what we were looking for. Since we were new to the area, she gave us a packet filled with information on the Columbus and New Albany area. We are grateful that Bev helped to make this new chapter in our lives a successful one!

- Jerry and Bernice Smith

Our home buying experience with Rob at Thomas & Company was excellent. He helped us find the right balance of house and location and guided us through the purchase process effectively. We are also listing our current house with Thomas & Company and expect that to go just as smoothly! Thanks to all!

- Lauren Potulski

Rob Riddle did a fantastic job with the sale of my parents' home. Having lost both parents in the past year, selling their home was a difficult task for my two sisters and me. Rob was very sensitive to our situation and allowed us to process each step before moving forward. He was always available when needed and responded promptly. I would recommend Rob to anyone needing a realtor. I must also compliment Andrea Maguire... Andrea responded to my calls and emails immediately and made the entire closing process a breeze. Our family has worked with Rob on two previous deals, so Rob is our guy and Thomas & Company our broker!

- Greg Spencer

Very positive! We got the house that we dreamed. Eventually we settled down in Columbus. Bev did a great job by showing us the different houses and giving the recommendations. We do appreciate your help.

- Meijiang Yun

Thomas & Company did a great job in helping us find our new home. Our agent Bev Klein was especially helpful, giving the right advice at the right time. Everything was well taken care of and all our questions were addressed promptly. We highly recommend them.

- Maimoona Jan-Rehman

Rob Riddle was our agent - he was flexible, knowledgeable, accommodating, and really went above and beyond to find us the house of our (my) dreams. We highly recommend Rob if you're looking for an agent!!

- Shelly Bowles

Kate and Tony are a professional and responsive team. With their guidance we were able to get our house in contract in 6 days! We had already moved to another state and they were invaluable in keeping the transaction moving smoothly along to close. I highly recommend them.

- Bryan Roberts

It was a pleasure to work with Kate & Tony and their realtors, especially Sue who helped us patiently through our home buying process. Overall our experience was great and they made the whole process fairly simple. I highly recommend Kate & Tony.

- Sid Arigapudi

The Thomas Team did a fantastic job helping us sell our house. They are excellent! We highly recommend them!

- Fritz and Fiona Hoefer

Kate & Tony's team has been phenomenal to work with. Their team approach to the sale of our home really made us feel we had an expert for each different part of the transaction Any time we had a question about what to do next, we found their team was already two steps ahead of us. We would highly recommend their team!

- Joe and Kelly Studer

Tony was truly a great realtor to work with, he and his team met all of our goals and helped us sell fast and for the best price! We would recommend him to anyone trying to sell in the Columbus area!

- Katy and Rob Gerth

Kate & Tony Thomas run a first-class business. We worked directly with Tony and he was professional, patient, and a great partner. The services that they provide are incredible. With a capable staff, almost everything is handled for you. From listing appointments, cleaning crews, stagers, etc. everything is provided and managed to a high level. They were able to sell our home for list price in 4 days! We were beyond happy and satisfied with our experience. I would highly recommend Kate & Tony Thomas - they are the best real estate team in New Albany!

- Brian and Kelly Hall

Kate and Tony were amazing in the sale of our home. We had to move out of state and put our house on the market quickly and they were instrumental in making that happen. They know the New Albany market extremely well and were always there for us to offer guidance. After the home inspections, some issues came up and Tony and Kate helped us get through everything in such a calm and professional manner. They also have a wonderful staff. Andrea, our client care manager, was excellent! She was always responsive and definitely knows her job well. Her level of customer service is unsurpassed. Being that we were out of state for the sale of our home we were concerned things might be difficult. Tony, Kate and their team ensured everything went smoothly and we can't recommend them enough!

- Tirtak and Shannon Mada

Selling was a very pleasant experience. Because of their knowledge of marketplace, we had a buyer within 4 days.

- Donna and Charles Dudley

It was a great pleasure to work with Kate & Tony Thomas. We had moved to another state, both have full-time jobs, so could not be directly involved in house-selling activities. They did that all. They developed a selling strategy based on reasonable investment in preparing a home for sale in return for maximizing sale price and minimizing time on market. They realized that strategy managing a number of home improvement, landscaping and cleaning companies, designers and vendors (at that, we were never overcharged, quite the opposite, mostly we paid less than expected). Finally, They sold the house. Everything worked exactly as they planned: just two days on market and full price. Always follow their advice. They knows what they are doing. Kate & Tony and their team were terrific. We highly recommend them to anyone interested in selling a home.

- Val and Marianna Vershinin

Had great service and would highly recommend your team.

- Sharon Royer

I have been in the real estate business for 18 years. Working on thousands of transactions. Your professionalism in real estate is a standard all should strive for. We would highly recommend anyone looking to buy or sell a home use your team!

- Scott & Tish Miller

Kate and Tony were phenomenal to work with! The entire office was extremely pleasant and professional. We sold our home faster than we anticipated and received more than the asking price. Their professional advice during the transaction was exceptional. They kept us informed of what was going on, and helped us through every step of the process. We are very grateful they persevered when we ran into obstacles during closing. They truly went above and beyond every expectation we had. The customer service provided by them is unsurpassed. We highly recommend them to anyone interested in buying or selling a home.

- Brian and Julie Ramsay

Kate & Tony and their team were terrific to work with on the sale of our home. They knew the market and were extremely helpful in guiding us through the process of getting our home prepared for sale.

- David and Lori Greeley

Kate & Tony are absolutely the best. Sold two houses for me, one in 4 days. Very professional and really know the market! Thanks to the Thomas Riddle team and their staff. 

- Amy Abbey

Kate & Tony each bring different skill sets into focus for meeting the mutual goal of selling and/or purchasing a home. I would highly recommend their partnership to anyone.

- Barb Robins

Absolutely loved working with Kate & Tony! As first time buyers they made the process so smooth and easy. IF we had any questions they were answered without hesitation. We felt like they were part of the family and gave us input/recommendations not only from a realtor perspective, but from a family/parent/friend perspective.

- Jeff and Amanda Bailey

Kate & Tony have been the best real estate experience we have had in both buying and selling our homes. Having been through six home sales that included relocation, we have experienced many ups and downs but with Kate & Tony it was all ups! They are the only team we would consider in the New Albany area.

- Joanne and Glenn Laney

I have worked with Kate and Tony both as the customer and as a corporate client. They go the extra mile in providing outstanding results and customer service. Not only are they true professionals, but they sincerely care about your welfare along the way. I feel I am part of their extended family and anyone working with them will have the same wonderful experience.

- Susan Daugherty

We would highly recommend Kate & Tony Thomas. They gave us the confidence that they would sell our home and did so in a short period of time. We would use them again to buy or sell a home. We feel the main thing that sets them apart from the other realtors is that Kate & Tony have the clients and network to bring buyers to our home which we had not experienced before.

- David and Tracy Milo

You folks rock! This experience has been so far removed from any previous home selling/purchasing we?ve ever engaged in. At first we thought we were hiring Kate and Tony to sell our house and buy a new one. Then we found out we also hired Lindy. Then to our amazement we discovered Andrea and Cherie were part of the team. Their team effort made this experience unique and astoundingly effective?.Thank you to the entire team. We will absolutely refer friends and family to you.

- Scott and Catherine Layson

From A to Z, Kate & Tony Thomas were the best realtors we've ever had! We wish we could take them with us if and when we move again!

- Rashmi Nemade and Guru Vasudeva

We have had the pleasure of being assisted both as buyers and sellers by Kate and Tony Thomas. Their service and follow up far exceeds previous experiences with other realtors.

- Lisa and Jeffrey Kehoe

Kate and Tony, along with their team, far exceeded any expectations we had. They always put our needs ahead of anything else. We feel blessed to have had them representing us.

- Jeff and Kim Tolnar

After meeting Kate and Tony, I knew they were the ones to sell my home. Their team is equally impressive. Everyone is topnotch! They are responsive, well-informed, thorough, gracious, and with real sincerity and thoughtfulness, anticipate any and every need. They understand that selling, buying, and moving can be a trying and overwhelming experience - and they make it smooth and simple. The Thomas Team proves they are worthy of the utmost trust, and always put the client's needs as #1. Most of all, Kate & Tony's integrity inspires unwavering confidence. For me, that is everything.

- Nancy Uher

If any Buyers or Sellers have been frustrated with the lack of proactive communication and representation with other realtors, then Kate & Tony and their friendly team will be a pleasant and welcome surprise.

- John and Bridgette Wooton

Working with Kate and Tony was awesome! They were so organized an helped keep us on track. They did a lot of the thinking/planning steps for us. They've got an excellent team who make the process fun and easy.

- Nicol and Eric Remeis

Add A Testimonial

Would you like to add a testimonial about your great experience? Use this fast and easy form to send us your comments and feedback.

New Albany Neighborhoods

Copyright © 2019 | Information deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. | Privacy Policy
Real Estate Web Design by Dakno Marketing.